"Paper Tiger" Review: James Gray's Thrilling Ride of Danger and Heart

A New Direction in James Gray’s Cinematic Journey

James Gray has always been known for his unique approach to storytelling, often blending genres in unexpected ways. His previous film, "Armageddon Time," was a coming-of-age memoir that defied the typical sentimentality of its genre. Now, with his latest film, "Paper Tiger," Gray takes a different route. While it appears to be a crime thriller on the surface, it actually offers a deeply sentimental take on a typically cold and calculated genre.

Given that both films are rooted in elements of Gray's own life, it's clear that the director's family experiences have played a significant role in shaping his work. Gray is a filmmaker who combines artistic rigor with a strong sense of humanity, and this balance is evident in "Paper Tiger."

The film is a taut exercise in suspense, featuring several intense sequences that push the tension to its limits. Hubris and wishful thinking lead a family into dangers they never anticipated, but at the heart of the story lies a warmhearted exploration of family dynamics. Despite their disagreements and conflicts, the characters consistently end their interactions with the simple yet powerful phrase: "I love you."

This personal touch is more than just a narrative device; it's a reflection of Gray's own experiences. The film's title, "Paper Tiger," suggests something that appears threatening but is ultimately not as dangerous as it seems. This theme resonates throughout the movie, especially when dealing with the Russian mob, which is portrayed as a formidable force rather than a comedic one.

Setting the Scene: Queens in 1986

"Paper Tiger" is set in Queens in 1986, a time when the Mafia was beginning to lose its grip and the Russian mob was making its mark in the construction industry. The story follows the Pearl family, consisting of Irwin (Miles Teller), Hester (Scarlett Johansson), and their two sons. They face typical financial struggles when Irwin's brother, Gary (Adam Driver), approaches him with an opportunity: a cleanup operation on a polluted local canal that could bring in a substantial amount of money.

Gary, a former cop turned rogue figure, believes he can convince the Russians to hire him to oversee the project, with Irwin serving as the head engineer. The potential payoff is tempting, and Hester insists that the payment be made in cash to avoid any legal complications.

The Unraveling of Plans

Irwin's skills and obsessive nature make him well-suited for the job, while Gary's connections and charisma add an unpredictable element to the mix. He shows up unannounced, bringing a catering crew from Peter Luger's Steakhouse and impressing the children with his piano playing and card tricks. However, his presence is also marked by a subtle menace, as evidenced by the gun in his ankle holster.

Gary's belief that the Russians are "paper tigers" proves to be a fatal mistake. Irwin's eagerness to show off his engineering skills leads him to take his sons on a nighttime risk assessment of the canal, a decision that puts them in grave danger. What starts as a routine inspection turns into a terrifying encounter with Russian gangsters engaged in illegal activities.

Escalating Tensions and Family Bonds

As the situation spirals out of control, the threats from the Russian mob escalate, and the involvement of Semion Bogoyavich (Victor Ptak) adds a new level of danger. Unlike some recent portrayals of Russian gangsters, "Paper Tiger" presents them as serious and dangerous figures, highlighting the real risks involved.

Gray returns to shooting on film after using digital for "Armageddon Time," enhancing the suspense with scenes that feel more visceral and intense. One particularly chilling sequence involves the Russians sneaking into the Pearl house and rearranging the furniture, a moment that feels more terrifying than it sounds.

A Personal Touch

The film's inspiration from actual events in Gray's life adds an unsettling layer to the narrative. It explains why a gripping thriller manages to maintain a focus on family ties. The performances are exceptional, with Driver embodying Gary's forced cockiness with ease and Johansson capturing the essence of an '80s Queens housewife. Teller delivers a compelling performance, showcasing the complexity of a character whose intentions and instincts are constantly at odds.

A Director's Vision

James Gray has spent over three decades exploring various genres, each time adding his unique spin. From crime with "Little Odessa" to romance with "Two Lovers," and period dramas like "The Immigrant," Gray has consistently pushed boundaries. "Paper Tiger" continues this trend, offering a thriller with a deep emotional core.

Despite its thrilling elements, "Paper Tiger" stands out for its heart. It's a film that balances danger with warmth, making it a standout in the genre.